employment matter guidelines
training and development



Contents:

Introduction

Analysing your workplace

Questions to Identify Training and Development Issues for Women

Suggested Actions to Take to Address Training and Development Issues for Women

Predominantly Male Workplace Issues

Predominantly Female Workplace Issues

Moving from Compliance to Leading Practice

Case studies

Related Links and Resources




   
 

Enhancing the skills and abilities of people not only has the potential to add value to the organisation but it also builds employee confidence and engagement. Committed and involved employees give organisations their competitive edge.


Providing an increasing number of female employees with training and development opportunities is a critical success factor in enabling your female employees to contribute to the best of their potential.

Keep in mind that women are not a homogenous group but reflect the growing diversity of the larger population. By recognising and valuing women’s differences (such as age, religion, cultural and linguistic backgrounds, disability, sexual orientation, etc.) and considering their needs in shaping training and development opportunities, your business stands to benefit from the diversity of their contributions.

The information provided here aims to assist you to start thinking about:

  • How you could analyse your workplace to identify any training and development issues for women.

  • Suggested actions you could take to address the training and development issues for women you have identified.

Not all issues, actions or examples suggested here will be relevant to your organisation. It is up to you to decide what is appropriate and relevant for your organisation to consider when analysing your workplace to identify issues for women, and taking actions to address these.

However, many of the suggestions outlined represent leading practice in contemporary human resource management and provide an opportunity to harness the contribution all your employees can make to productivity and the achievement of organisational goals.


 


Back to top






To assist you to analyse your workplace to identify training and development issues for women, we suggest you:

  • revisit your workforce profile to find where your female employees are situated within your organisation.

  • consult with your employees. Identify not only their training needs but also preferences in delivery methods, timing and location of training sessions. This is particularly important for older workers or employees with caring responsibilities.

  • examine your existing training and development policies and practices. Different organisations have different opportunities, depending upon their business needs. However, some examples are:

    -         Formal courses (held internally and externally)

    -         Critical task force involvement

    -         Mentoring schemes

    -         Peer support programs

    -         Graduate development programmes

    -         Leadership development

    -         Job rotation and multi-skilling

    -         Job-sharing as a method of knowledge transfer

    -         Secondments

    -         Development assignments

    -         Shadowing assignments

    -         Temporary transfers and acting roles

    -         Multi-disciplinary teams

    -         Internships

Back to top


 


 

 

Remember, your organisation is unique and may therefore have unique issues. However, the following questions may be helpful when analysing your workplace.

 

Are decisions made about who attends training transparent and gender and age-neutral' Would decision-making processes withstand the rigour of a review by an independent third party'

Are you using skills audits to identify existing skills of employees that could be tapped for professional development and organisational benefit' (eg. language skills/cultural experiences of women of diverse backgrounds')

Is training offered on the basis of identified training needs, for example, through performance appraisals, training needs analyses, etc'

Is there a culture where learning is seen as ongoing and part of everyone’s job'

Do your role descriptions focus on skills needed to perform the role rather than on years of experience'

Are the percentages of female, male, pregnant and temporary employees who receive training representative of their employment in your workplace'

Are similar resources invested in developing your female staff compared with your male staff, in a given organisational area, level or age group'

Are percentages of female and male employees who are studying externally comparable'

Are the courses being undertaken by women in traditionally female-dominated or ‘soft skill’ areas only' Are women equally represented in business, professional skills, finance and management disciplines'

Are you certain that all women within your organisation understand that they can apply for learning and development opportunities' Is there the belief that they will not get accepted because of their status, gender or age causing them not to apply'

Do both women and men get high-risk, high-visibility development assignments'

Are people able to access a range of training opportunities for example, technical and management training, regardless of their gender, age, work status or family or other responsibilities'

Do less than full-time staff or those working flexibly get trained equitably compared with their full-time peers'

Do women with caring responsibilities have the same access to training and development as their female and male colleagues without caring responsibilities'

Are your take-up rates for female employees and their male colleagues similar for all types of training and development, including leadership and supervisory programs and in traditionally male-dominated areas'

Is there a consistent, formal approach to offering training and development across the organisation'

Are training and development opportunities allocated to staff objectively (eg. on the basis of their duties, skill development needs, career interests, etc)'

Is training held at a time when employees with family or other responsibilities (for example, related to community responsibilities or religious practice) will easily be able to attend'

Is training offered on alternate dates and times to allow those working less than full-time hours to attend'

If your organisation has a High Potential Employee programme are percentages of male and female participants comparable'

Is training delivered in appropriate formats to take account of different learning styles, e.g. regarding language or age'

 

 

Back to top

 




To
comply with the Act, you need to take actions to address the training and development issues for women you identified. You do not need to do everything all at once and you can aim to achieve equal opportunity over time.

To be
waived from reporting in following years, you must clearly demonstrate that you have taken all reasonably practicable measures to address training and development  issues for women you have identified (for example, your issue might be inequity in women and men accessing training and development opportunities).

The following suggestions will help you to start thinking about actions you could take to address any training and development  issues you have identified.

Keep in mind that:

  • Not all of these actions may be relevant to your organisation. You will need to decide whether you choose to do all, some, or none of the suggested actions and whether you wish to tailor suggested actions to suit the needs of your workplace.

  •  If your workplace analysis demonstrates your organisation has no issues for women in this employment matter, you would not need to take any actions.


Developing Policy and Procedures

  • Put in place a general policy on how training and development opportunities are provided.

  • The policy could also include an organisational commitment to training about workplace diversity issues (such as valuing employee differences, managing diversity and work/life balance).

  • The policy should take into account workforce planning and organisational strategy, and be formulated with an awareness that the organisation will need to access women’s skills increasingly in a shrinking labour market.

  • Develop a quality, consistent process for providing training and development opportunities (eg. linked to performance appraisals or skills audit etc).

  • Ensure that training and learning programs are delivered in a variety of ways to take into account different learning styles, eg. older or linguistically diverse workers.

  • Monitor both female and male employees’ access to training and development opportunities to identify inequities which may be experienced by particular groups of women, for example, women with language difficulties and disabilities, or mature-aged women.

  • Ensure that the training policy gives recognition to prior experience and learning outside the organisation, and beyond previous job performance or formal (ie. academic or trade) qualifications.

  • Ensure that managers who make decisions regarding access to training and development opportunities are well versed in the policy and understand the process for providing equitable training and development opportunities.

Reviewing Access to Training and Development Issues

  • Review the emphasis you place on different courses (for example, people management, core technical and business skills training) for both your female and male employees.

  • Ensure that the training policy provides training which can enable all employees to access possible development and promotional opportunities.

  • Identify the jobs women and men choose not to do and investigate why these choices are being made (eg. sales jobs with bonus schemes which encourage staff to poach customers from each other, inappropriate entertaining venues being used for customers, a perceived amount of unnecessary travel, etc).

  • Survey employees about the equity of training and development opportunities.

  • Identify who is and is not taking up training and development opportunities. Make sure that access to opportunities is not impeded by unintentional barriers, such as limited English language skills preventing an employee from upgrading other skills, or the supposition that staff working less than full-time are unable to attend training, or that if you work part-time, you will not be offered learning and development opportunities .

Providing Training and Development Opportunities

  • Require that all staff have a career discussion with their manager or supervisor that includes an annual training and development plan.

  • Ensure that training needs are an integral component of performance reviews.

  • Train your managers to effectively and objectively use the performance and development process for both women and men (eg. how to give positive and negative performance feedback to female and male staff).

  • Encourage managers to discuss training and development interests and opportunities for the future with both female and male employees.

  • Hold managers accountable for implementing the development plan by including it in their workplace and/or performance agreement.

  • Challenge management assumptions about why women are not provided with the same access to training and development as their male peers.

  • Provide employees with access to different modes of training (eg. on-the-job, rotation, coaching, and distance education).

  • Encourage staff to participate in learning experiences that build diverse skills and broaden career options.

  • Provide managers and employees with diversity training, covering diversity awareness and diversity management issues such as teamwork, conflict resolution and interpersonal skills.

  • Ensure that this training highlights the value that recognition of diversity can bring to the organisation.

Providing Access to Training to Employees with Family Responsibilities

  • Provide training when both your female and male employees can access it, for example, during normal work hours.

  • Consider paying for or subsidising dependant care costs, if staff have responsibilities that prevent them from attending training held outside normal work hours.

  • Hold training courses on days when employees who work flexibly can be available for training. 

  • Consider different ways of providing training for example, distance or online programs that do not require staff to be at work to complete.

Developing High Potential Employees

  • Encourage managers to coach talented female and male employees in their group.

  • Shift behaviours and attitudes by encouraging senior women as well as senior men to mentor and coach female and male employees.

  • Use a tracking system to identify talented female and male employees and assist them to gain a broad range of experience that will help their career advancement.

  • Ensure that both female and male employees get on-the-job experience in functional and line management positions.

  • Encourage women and men to consider a wide range of career options within the organisation, such as in non-traditional areas.

  • Provide both female and male high potential staff with training and development experiences that will assist them, where appropriate, to fast-track their career.

  • Ensure that you do not, deliberately or otherwise, support an ‘up or out’ policy. Also ensure that your programs acknowledge that some people may not be wanting to advance through the organisational structure at certain times, and may prefer to plateau for a while instead. Spread the message that this preference does not in any way affect those employees’ performance in his or her current role, nor the contribution they make to the organisation.  

  • Provide internal and/or external career development training.

  • Tailor additional training to address any skill gaps identified in skills audits.

  • Allow all staff a particular allocation of training of their choice.

  • Support both female and male staff wishing to take on formal study, for example, paid study leave or financial assistance.

  • Make managers accountable for developing both female and male staff through their performance appraisal or bonus system.

Supporting High Potential Employees

  • Ask senior managers to act as mentors to both female and male employees. Consider the benefits of having mentors from different backgrounds available to provide mentoring support.

  • Put mechanisms in place to hold managers accountable for supporting employees when they are placed in a new assignment (eg. regular feedback sessions and personal development plans).

  • Ask senior women to act as role models to encourage women to continue to train and develop. Again, consider the benefits of being able to provide role models that correspond to women’s diversity.

  • Support attendance at women’s network functions, or set up your own women’s network where female staff can hear from, meet and be inspired by a range of other women.

·     Recognising Talent for Training and Development

  • Check that you are investing in both female and male staff of all ages to improve their effectiveness in their current job and enhance their future development.

  • Conduct skills audits to identify existing skills of employees that could be further developed for professional and organisational benefits (eg. recognise and develop second language skills of women employees who do not speak English as a first language).

  • Review requirements for formal qualifications. Ensure that these and/or other credentials are not an unnecessary barrier to further training and advancement. Consider qualifications acquired overseas where relevant.

  • Recognise prior learning, including existing skills and informal education.  

  • Review your processes to ensure they are inclusive of women’s life experiences and skills as well as men’s.

·     Communicating Training and Development Opportunities

  • Advertise training opportunities widely, not just within those areas judged to be immediately relevant.

  • Provide training for managers and supervisors on work/life issues (eg. needs of part-time and shift workers, and flexible work considerations).

  • Use training forums to ‘mainstream’ EEO issues (eg. cover ‘valuing and managing difference’ and ‘harassment-free workplaces’ in induction training and ongoing management or leadership training modules).

  • Communicate company commitment to valuing and managing differences through induction training, and by providing diversity training for managers and employees at all levels of the organisation.

  • Encourage managers to discuss training and development opportunities and interests when providing feedback or conducting performance appraisals.

  • Publicise your training and development policy and procedures widely within the organisation. Consider making them available in other languages for employees who have difficulty with English language fluency.

  • Ensure that both female and male employees, and employees on short-term and long-term leave have access to information on training and development policy and procedures. Educate managers on how to allocate training and development opportunities effectively and in a non-discriminatory way.

  • Hold managers accountable for developing female and male employees by including this requirement in managers’ workplace and performance agreements.

  • Encourage managers to lead by example with respect to providing equal opportunity in training and development.

Back to top






An equal opportunity program must deal with the specific needs and issues of your organisation. Such a program identifies and outlines the issues you are addressing and the initiatives you will put in place to achieve results. The most significant issues facing organisations with a majority of male employees may be:

  • A lack of applications from female employees.

  • A low proportion of women in management.

  • A low proportion of women in non-traditional occupational categories eg. trades, labouring, plant and machinery operators, engineers, corporate lawyers, banking.

  • Problems retaining female employees.

  • Low level of representation of women at graduate level or in training program intakes despite large numbers of female graduates and applicants.

Is information about training available and accessible'

Have you identified a gap in skills and/or experience of women wanting to progress into management or specialist roles'

Are trainers and training materials non-sexist'

Have you identified the training needs of all staff'

Have you trained all employees on the nature and purpose of an equal opportunity program' Are employees supportive of this program'

Have you introduced cross-skilling and job rotation'

Do you encourage women to do in-house training'

Do you encourage women to attend management courses'

Do you encourage and support women attending professional development training'

Are all managers trained in issues of diversity, EEO and gender' Do they encourage women to participate in learning and development'

Do you have a mentoring scheme for women'




Back to top

 

 



EOWA is aware that some organisations have been implementing very good Human Resources policies for a number of years but have under-reported on this information because they don’t see it as relevant to equal opportunity for women. All HR policies and practices, whether formal or informal, affect all the people in your organisation and are therefore relevant to equal opportunity for women.
 

Do women access training in a proportion that is reflective of the total number of women employed'

Would it be useful for women staff to attend training on identifying and valuing their skills'

Are there particular female-dominated occupations that have less access to training' If so, can anything be done to rectify this'

Do you have funding allocated for training'

Do women of all ages attend and receive training'

Do you have a process in place to provide recognition of the skills of older workers as they may not have formal qualifications but have on the job experience'

 



Back to top



 




What do leading compliance organisations do'

Moving from compliance to waived status requires you to demonstrate clearly that you have analysed all seven employment matters as well as the issues raised through your staff consultation process, and have taken all reasonably practicable measures to address recruitment and selection issues for women that you have identified. The following categories of action may help to generate ideas of what can be achieved to address the issues of women in your workplace and increase the opportunities to recruit and select the best possible talent for the job.

Data Review

  • Conduct a review of all training and development systems to ensure that there is no bias or unfairness that inhibits the training and development of women in the workplace.

  • Work with team leaders and managers to identify specific training and development needs within the local work groups and assist them to overcome the blockages to training and developing team members.

Strategies

  • Link the training and development of men and women to the overall goals of the business and the success of local teams.

  • Develop and implement a training process that is linked to performance and the needs of the individual, their job and the business.

Policies

  • Re-visit current policies to ensure that they reflect current training practices such as online training, project based on-the-job training etc.

Culture Change

  • Provide development opportunities for top performers including work experience in the corporate office, executive team meetings and meetings with CEO.

  • Hold managers and team leaders accountable for the training and development of all staff within their work group. As part of the appraisal process, ensure that they are able to demonstrate how they have supported and encouraged staff to access the appropriate training to meet their needs.

Examples of Initiatives

  • Each year, ensure that the training and career development of “high potential” staff are reviewed by the management team.

  • Organise mentoring and/or coaching of high potential staff by executives.

  • Conduct 3600 leadership assessments at all levels of management.

  • Select high achievers to manage projects.


Back to top

 

 

 



All case studies are available from the EOWA website: www.eowa.gov.au.

Mixed Gender

Coles Group’s
goal was to create a workplace where people want to work and where the diversity of the workforce reflects that of its customers and the wider community. An extensive range of training programs and development opportunities for women were put in place to ensure this was achieved.

John Wiley and Sons’ annual performance appraisal and development assessment was not seen as a fair process by some staff. In addition, there was a lack of information about internal training resources. The organisation made a number of changes to address these issues.

Sara Lee Household & Body Care, a small manufacturer of soap and other detergents, recognised that they had a low representation of women at senior level and also in non-traditional areas and took action to address this.

Sea World’s HR Manager recognised the importance of making choices available to working women and that all employees need broad-based skills to allow them to grow and advance in employment.


Predominantly Male


Baulderstone Hornibrook, a large predominantly male construction company, become aware that female employees were not receiving regular performance reviews and feedback and to support the career development of female employees. They took measures to successfully address these issues.

SAP Australia Pty Limited
believed that it was imperative to establish career paths for traditionally female held, non-skilled positions and that encouragement was needed to ensure career mobility for all employees within the company.

GM Holden recognised the need to gain greater access to a wider talent pool as one way to attract and retain more women; in particular into non-traditional roles such as engineering. A Holden Women’s Council was established to address issues of importance to women, and has succeeding in helping women to develop specific skills.


Predominantly Female

The Australian National Credit Union (ANCU), was strongly committed to its staff and customers and recognised the need to continue providing staff with ongoing training and development.

Autoliv Australia’s aim was to create more promotional opportunities for female staff. As a result, women mainly completed the Engineering Production Certificate course, and more women were promoted to higher positions within the company.

Bevilles Jewellers identified that regular, constructive feedback on performance was needed with staff. Development needs were identified needs and strategies implemented to achieve improvement and change.

Country Road conducted focus groups on enterprise bargaining and analysed various workplace data, and realised that they needed to improve career development opportunities in the Sales workforce, of which 76% was women.

Jetset Tours Pty Ltd experienced a difficult period with economic restrictions and a need for economic survival and change management. Through analysis of their workplace profile and focus groups, Jetset needed to modify training hours to enable improvement in employee attendance and train potential leaders in leadership and management skills. This resulted in senior roles being filled by existing female employees.


 

Back to top





To download a comprehensive list of links and resources across the seven Employment Matters, click here.

Internet Sites

Diversity Australia
www.diversityaustralia.gov.au is a newly developed portal for diversity management, directed mainly to business, including business educators.  The site is provided by the Department of Immigration, Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs and complements another new portal that has a government and community focus. Both sites will be available in April 2002.

Diversity Council Australia
http://www.dca.org.au
Formerly known as the Council for Equal Opportunity in Employment Ltd, Diversity Council Australia is the most highly regarded diversity and equal employment opportunity (EEO) support network of its kind for employers with a distinguished history and acknowledged role as a leader in employer representation.

Publications

Bagshaw, M. (2004). Is diversity divisive' A positive training approach. Industrial and Commercial Training, Vol. 36 No. 4, pp. 153-157.

Bendick, M., Egan, M. & Lofhjelm, S. (2001). Workforce diversity training: From anti-discrimination compliance to organizational development. HR: Human Resource Planning, Vol. 24 No. 2, pp. 10-25.

Boyle, M. (2005). Most mentoring program stink: But yours doesn’t have to.  Training Vol. 42 No. 8, pp. 8-15.

Lewis, A. & Fagenson, E. (1995). Strategies for developing women managers: How well do the fulfil their objectives' Journal of Management Development. Vol 14 No. 2, pp. 39-53.

Long, S. (2002). Mentoring: A personal reflection. New Library World. Vol. 103 No. 1174, pp. 94-97.

Maurer, T. & Rafuse, N. (2001). Learning, not litigating: Managing employee development and avoiding claims of age discrimination. Academy of Management Executive, Vol. 15 No. 4, pp. 110-121.

McGregor, L. (2000). Mentoring an Australian experience. Career Development International. Vol. 5 No. 4/5, pp. 244-249.

Newton, B. (2006). Training an age-diverse workforce. Industrial and Commercial Training, Vol. 38 No. 2, pp. 93-97.

Taylor, W. (2005). A mentoring hand. The Age, My Career Section, p. 11, 26/11/2005.

 

Back to top